Comments on: Edward Cullen or Jacob Black??

by: Ranin

Sun, 07 Jun 2009 22:32:11 +0100

Hi all.
I just want to say that I actually began to really like the book when Bella told Jacob that she loved him, because that made the whole story even more interesting and more exciting to read, that made you wonder about more things. Of course I want Bella to be with Edward for ever, but if it had continued about only Edward + Bella all the time the book would just have “died” (like get very boring), so Jacob’s feelings about Bella made the whole thing more interesting and there was finally an obstacle that didn’t include war or something but this time it was love for two different persons. And besides Bella knew from the beginning that she doesn’t LOVE Jacob in the way that she loves Edward. Jacob is only a best friend that she loves deeply, but Edward is her boyfriend and future husband.

by: Frustrated anti-jacob

Fri, 03 Apr 2009 12:55:29 +0100

i agree with the brazilian girl, i am FURIOUS that bella fell inlove with jacob. It pretty much ruined all the magic I felt about the book and about Bella and Edwards relationship. I’m really disappointed, I loved the bond her and Jacob shared, but when he started playing with her head about all of that love stuff it was hard to read, I was beginning to not like him and THEN when she admitted she loved him too I was so disgusted I had to put the book down and decided the next day I would finish it, I was close to calling it quits though. I’m still not sure I will read Breaking Dawn, I might just stick with twilight, the story that I loved before it became conflicted.

by: Catharina

Tue, 23 Dec 2008 14:57:22 +0000

Hi, I’m brazilian, so I’m sorry if my english sucks. I agree with you, I hate Bella, she wasn’t supposed to love Jacob! I thought that Bella and Edward’s love was perfect, but now, I think it’s destroyed. I can’t believe that Stephenie Meyer did it to us! No one can love two persons! If it happens, the love isn’t true. Bye!